Read my lips: go wireless, get cancer
Friday, June 13, 2008
To the editor:
I read with incredulity the letter published in your paper with the uninformed and biased caption, (Re: "Cell tower critic not switched on to facts," Letters, June 11).
As medical science regarding the dangers of various forms of electromagnetic radiation continues to advance, there is little dispute in the peer-reviewed literature about real dangers to citizens.
The mean-spirited, dismissive rejoinder by Mr. Wilson to Mr. Bowling is misleading, disrespectful to your readers and simply wrong. It portends a disdain for the health of your people and exhibits a serious lack of knowledge regarding the ever-emerging science regarding the myriad adverse impacts of the electromagnetic spectrum on human health and ecological balance.
The incidence of serious illnesses among those exposed to multiple forms of biologically active radiation is dramatically increasing, and includes conditions such as sleep disturbances, unexplained anxiety and various forms of cancer.
It is important for citizens to understand that while the complexities of the electromagnetic radiation health-risk issue continue to create fertile ground for mobile phone industry-supported obfuscation, the scientific facts are clear that danger looms for users of wireless devices, those who live in the vicinity of wireless infrastructure and the general public .
Dr. George Carlo,
Science and Public Policy
Institute, Washington, D.C.
© Vancouver Courier 2008
|Copyright © 2008 CanWest Interactive, a division of CanWest MediaWorks Publications, Inc.. All rights reserved.|
Mobile phone tumour fears
- Reporter: Laura Sparkes
- Broadcast Date: June 12, 2008
David Smith faithfully sold mobile phones for 10 years. Little did he know, he was getting paid to sell something that he believes has now ruined his life.
"I think it would be very foolish, very foolish, to assume there is no relationship and not take any precautions," David said.
"What makes me angry is that they continue to sell these phones without making sure that they are safe."
The evidence is mounting. Brain tumours are on the increase - even neurosurgeons are concerned. The industry stands firm, however, not all of them.
David was just 30 years old when he underwent three operations to remove the tumour as big as a golf ball, around his acoustic nerve.
During the surgery, the nerve was removed and another was accidentally damaged, causing David to lose muscular control in his face.
"I believe mobile phones gave me this tumour and I blame the mobile phone companies," David said.
"I was angry at the mobile phone companies and at the telecommunication companies because they've put this product on the market without the proper research to what it does, I guess they've used us as guinea pigs."
The tumour was situated just behind his right ear.
"I used to use my right ear as my phone ear, but I don't do that anymore because I can't hear out of it," David said. "I used to use the mobile phone maybe one or two hours a day for the 10 years or so before I was diagnosed."
David's tumour is one that studies have linked to mobile phone use.
Professor Bruce Armstrong is head of Sydney University's Public Health Dept. He's spent 10 years looking at the research between mobile phones and brain tumours.
There was evidence of a twofold increase in risk of tumours.
While David is trying to piece his life back together, he worries for the millions who constantly use their mobile.
"You see 10 year olds running around the street using mobile phones, I wonder how they'll affect the development of their brains," said David.
Enrico Grani too blames his brain tumour on heavy mobile phone use over 10 years.
"I had an analogue phone it was like a toy, you know what I mean, you get a new toy you talk on the phone," said Enrico.
He was diagnosed with a meningioma in the right parietal globe.
After the operation, he was in a coma for three days and suffered a stroke.
"I blame the cell phone industry blinded by greed, they've known about this for many, many years but they still deny it," said Enrico.
None of this surprises those in the business of brain surgery. One prominent Canberra Neurologist has written a research paper on the link between mobile phones and brain tumours. He believes mobile phones will be the next great public health issue and he compares their effects with those of smoking and asbestos. He's calling on government and industry to take immediate steps to reduce exposure of consumers to mobile phones.
As a Neurosurgeon Richard Bit-tar has seen a rise in brain tumours in the last 15 years, but says its hard to point the finger solely at mobile phone use. Yet Richard tries to use his mobile phone only on loudspeaker or uses a nearby landline when possible.
"There is certainly an element of concern not only from myself but from a lot of my colleagues. A lot of my neurosurgery colleagues go even further and really try and minimise the amount of mobile phone use they engage in, that reflects an underlying concern that there may well be a relationship," said Richard.
His warning to consumers?
"Minimise the amount of time you spend with your mobile phone up against your ear."
We asked the Australian Mobile Telecommunications Association's Chris Althaus if he was worried about getting a tumour: "No."
Does he use his phone every day?
"I use it every day and I use it a lot every day, I'm very comfortable personally with the way the research effort conveys to markets like Australia and globally the level of safety you can enjoy when using a mobile phone," said Chris.
But David had a different view.
"It's ruined the life I had previously had, all these plans and ideas and so much hope for the future and now that's all changed. I've had to reevaluate everything," said David.