Thursday, September 25, 2008

Wireless radiation concerns parents

Present petition to French school board after studies showing concerns

Suzanne Fournier, The Province

Published: Thursday, September 25, 2008

Kerrisdale computer consultant Carl Katz doesn't want his two children bathed in a sea of radiation all day from wireless technology at their school.

Katz and the Parents for Safe Computing this week presented a petition signed by

80 parents troubled by the health effects of Wi-Fi (wireless fidelity) on their children to the Conseil Scolaire Francophone, the public French school board that oversees 40 schools in B.C.

Carl Katz, whose two kids go to Rose-des-Vents school, is concerned about wireless technology because he says studies have shown that electromagnetic radiation of the level emitted by laptops with wireless is of concern to small children.

Carl Katz, whose two kids go to Rose-des-Vents school, is concerned about wireless technology because he says studies have shown that electromagnetic radiation of the level emitted by laptops with wireless is of concern to small children.

Gerry Kahrmann - The Province
"I've done very exhaustive research and looked at the international studies on wireless technology and I can tell you that Health Canada is about 15 years behind the research in warning parents and the public," said Katz, 47.

"The industry-sponsored studies say Wi-Fi is no problem but the independent research in the U.S. and Britain has shown that electromagnetic radiation of the level emitted by laptops with a wireless connection should cause a great deal of concern, especially with children whose bodies are much more sensitive. I'm very concerned."

Katz has two children, Nicole and Zachary, in Grade 1 and Grade 6 at Rose-des-Vents school, which recently spent about $500,000 on new wireless connections for the kids' laptops.

Katz's group wants the French school board to switch from wireless technology back to cable, which they say carries less risk of exposing children to harmful levels of electromagnetic fields or EMFs.

"The school [officials]told us we'd be hobbling our children and setting them back a generation in technology and that's just ridiculous," says Katz. "I removed Wi-Fi from our house and my son is still very adept on a computer."

Paul de la Riva, spokesman for the board, said it adheres to Health Canada's Safety Code 6, which deals with "limits of human exposure" to electromagnetic fields.

"We rely on Health Canada to determine what is safe for kids, and as far as we know there is no health advisory on wireless technology, but we're not researchers and we're not the experts here," he said.

"If we did go back to a wired classroom it wouldn't allow each child from Grade 4 to 10 to have a computer at their desk. We will look into it but at this time we don't think scientists have agreed there are definite health effects."

Research from Sweden, Britain and the U.S. has found that EMFs of the level emitted by cellphones and wireless technology do impact the human body and may be linked to symptoms like headache, fatigue, tinnitus, memory deficits, irregular heart beat and some cancers.

In the U.K., government adviser Lawrie Challis has warned that children should not put laptop computers with Wi-Fi connections on their lap because of the health risks.

He wants to monitor the effects of wireless technology on children.

In the U.S., the Health Protection Agency asked recently for "more research into new technologies."

In B.C., there are no studies under way on the health effects on children of wireless technology.

"There is no evidence of adverse effects on kids at this time," said Ray Copes, director of environmental health for the B.C. Centres for Disease Control.

"It could reduce a child's exposure to move the laptop from their lap onto the desk, but to what extent should you make a precautionary statement when we have no firm evidence, especially compared to other proven risks?" he asked.

Vancouver School Board spokesman David Weir said: "The school district takes counsel from Health Canada and other federal authorities on this issue and they have not issued a health advisory on wireless networks."

sfournier@theprovince.com