We don't often talk about breakthroughs when we write about EMFs, but this time it's justified.
Read all about it at:
Louis Slesin, PhD
Editor, Microwave News
A Report on Non-Ionizing Radiation
Phone: +1 (212) 517-2800; Fax: +1 (212) 734-0316
Mail: 155 East 77th Street, Suite 3D
New York, NY 10075, U.S.A.
Cellphone health study on hold
December 14, 2008
It's supposed to be the mother of all studies into cellphones and their potential link to head cancers, a definitive report that the multibillion-dollar wireless industry has partially funded.
But the published analysis of the 13-country Interphone study is two years late and likely to be delayed further as the more than 50 scientists involved bicker over how to interpret the results, knowing full well that any hint at health risks would have a profound impact on the industry.
The stakes are high, and the steps toward the final outcome are being closely watched. More than three billion people around the world use a cellphone, and while sales next year are expected to fall slightly amid tough economic times, wireless gadgets like the BlackBerry and iPhone are woven into the fabric of our daily lives.
Participating countries are free to publish their individual national results, and eight countries have.
Among Nordic countries, there are already hints that cellphone use for 10 years or longer increases the risk of developing glioma and acoustic neurinoma tumours on the side of the head where a handset is held.
It's far from definitive, but suggestive enough to spark closer scrutiny from some scientific corners. Growing impatient and citing the public's right to get "the whole pattern," a group of scientists calling themselves The BioInitiative Working Group are urging the remaining five countries - including Canada - to hand over their results "without further delay."
"There is a lot of data that's been obtained, but not all of it, and the people sitting on it are being obstructionists for a particular reason," said Dr. Martin Blank, a professor of cellular biophysics at Columbia University in New York City and one of 11 scientists who signed a letter earlier this month asking for speedy release of the data.
None of the five countries, including Australia, New Zealand, Israel and Italy, has complied with the request. The scientists heading up Canada's portion of Interphone haven't even responded.
"They don't want the results to come out. It's as simple as that," said Blank.
Three cities are part of the Canadian study: Ottawa, Montreal and Vancouver. The Canadian Wireless Telecommunications Association, which has consistently maintained that cellphones are not harmful to use and comply with all Canadian safety standards, contributed $1 million to the Ottawa portion through a third-party organization.
However, the association said it isn't aware of when the results will be published and doesn't know the reason for the delay.
"I have no idea why the full Interphone study has not been released," said spokesperson Marc Choma. "Interphone does not report to us.
"Dr. Daniel Krewski, a professor in the department of epidemiology and community medicine at the University of Ottawa, is heading up the Ottawa study. He did not reply to an interview request, either directly or through his office.
In a May interview, however, Krewski told the Star there was a concern that certain biases in the Interphone results - such as study subjects overestimating their long-term cellphone use - may be skewing the analysis.
His counterpart in Montreal, Dr. Jack Siemiatycki at the University of Montreal, told the Star in an e-mail exchange last week that the BioInitiative Working Group has no greater or lesser claim to the data than anyone else.
"There are no people in the world who want to see the Interphone results published more than the Interphone collaborators ourselves," Siemiatycki said.
"It has proven very difficult to achieve an agreed upon manuscript for publication.
"The reasons are "not sinister," he assured. "They have to do with facts and data that can legitimately be interpreted in different ways.
"Asked why Canada hasn't released an analysis of its own data as eight other countries have, Siemiatycki said it was agreed at the outset that Canada would release its study after Interphone is published. For this reason the Canadian data, while collected, has not yet been analyzed."And doing so won't be a trivial task," he added.
Australia and Israel have also not published their national Interphone results, but the scientists heading up each country's research have said publicly, including in interviews with the Star, that there are concerning patterns emerging for long-term use.
It's part of the reason why Toronto Public Health and the University of Pittsburgh Cancer Institute, in what some considered a controversial move, both recommended this summer that children minimize their use of cellphones and use headsets as a precaution.
Blank isn't surprised there's a concern."I think there's going to be a building up of momentum," he said.
FACTS ABOUT INTERPHONE STUDY
Members: Canada, Australia, Italy, Israel, Japan, Denmark, Sweden, France, Germany, Finland, New Zealand, Norway, United Kingdom.Cancers studied: gliomas, meningiomas, acoustic neurinomas and parotid gland tumours.Participating Canadian cities: Ottawa, Vancouver, Montreal.Study period: 2000 to 2004.Complete published analysis: Expected in 2006. Still waiting.Age group studied: 39 to 50 year olds.Countries that have published own results: Japan, Denmark, Sweden, France, Germany, Norway, United Kingdom, Finland.Countries that haven't published: Canada, Israel, Australia, Italy, New Zealand.
Cancer Projected To Become Leading Cause Of Death Worldwide In 2010
ScienceDaily (Dec. 9, 2008) - Despite the recent good news that cancer incidence and death rates for men and women in the United States continue to decline, cancer is projected to become the leading cause of death worldwide in the year 2010, and low- and middle-income countries will feel the impact of higher cancer incidence and death rates more sharply than industrialized countries.
The nation's leading cancer organizations joined forces Dec. 9 at an event called Conquering Cancer: A Global Effort, to focus attention on the growing global cancer burden and discuss efforts needed to address the problem. The International Agency for Research on Cancer (IARC) released the new edition of the World Cancer Report. The American Cancer Society, the Lance Armstrong Foundation, and Susan G. Komen for the Cure discussed how each organization is addressing the global cancer problem and together issued a call to action for the incoming United States presidential administration and Congress. In addition, a new international documentary film entitled "Cancer Is." was premiered.
According to the new report, the burden of cancer doubled globally between 1975 and 2000. It is estimated that it will double again by 2020 and nearly triple by 2030. This translates to far greater numbers of people living with - and dying from - the disease. The report estimates that there were some 12 million new cancer diagnoses worldwide this year, and more than seven million people will die from the disease. The projected numbers for the year 2030 are 20-26 million new diagnoses and 13-17 million deaths.
The growing cancer burden includes global increases of incidence of about one percent each year, with larger increases in China, Russia, and India. Reasons for the increased rates include adoption of Western habits in less developed countries, such as tobacco use and higher-fat diets, and demographic changes, including a projected population increase of 38 percent in less developed countries between 2008 and 2030.
In addition to increases in cancer incidence and death rates, the report identifies challenges in cancer care, especially in Africa, where pain management and palliative care are very limited because any use of narcotics is prohibited by law in several countries.
Sharing the stage were John R. Seffrin, Ph.D., chief executive officer, American Cancer Society; Lance Armstrong, founder and chairman, Lance Armstrong Foundation; Hala Moddelmog, president and chief executive officer, Susan G. Komen for the Cure; Peter Boyle, B.Sc., Ph.D., D.Sc.(Med), director, International Agency for Research on Cancer; Alejandro Mohar Betancourt, M.D., Sc.D., director, National Cancer Institute of Mexico, and Bill Gregory, a throat cancer survivor.
The American Cancer Society's Seffrin said, "For all of our 95 years the Society has pursued the vow of our founders to eliminate cancer in all humankind. We recognize that cancer strikes without regard to borders or socioeconomic status, and we support cancer control initiatives in more than 20 countries, and fund capacity building and tobacco control grants in some 70 countries - including the launch next week of our tobacco Quitline® in India. It is my hope that by bringing proven interventions to places in the world impacted most by this disease, we can diminish needless suffering and save many lives.
"Armstrong explained his foundation's international work, saying, "Since announcing the launch of our international cancer awareness campaign at the Clinton Global Initiative less than three months ago, we are already in discussions with more than 20 nations, NGOs and business leaders to advance this issue. Even in a challenging economy, people realize that with cancer there is progress to be made and prevention measures to be taken."
"Breast cancer alone will be diagnosed in 25 million women over the next 25 years. Susan G. Komen for the Cure already has changed the way we talk about and treat breast cancer in the United States, and we're bringing what we've learned to developing countries in Asia, Africa, Latin America, the Middle East and Eastern Europe. This 'global health diplomacy' approach, with its focus on better access to care, is already educating and empowering women worldwide, and it is critical if we're to save lives and resolve the growing global cancer crisis," said Hala Moddelmog, president and CEO of Susan G. Komen for the Cure.
Explaining the results of the report, Dr. Boyle said, "The rapid increase in the global cancer burden represents a real challenge for health systems worldwide. However, there is a clear message of hope: although cancer is a devastating disease, it is largely preventable. We know that preventive measures such as tobacco control, reduction of alcohol consumption, increased physical activity, vaccinations for hepatitis B and human papillomavirus (HPV), and screening and awareness could have a great impact on reducing the global cancer burden." [ they never touch environment]
"We appreciate the opportunity to stand with leading cancer organizations in the United States to make global cancer a priority. In Mexico, we have seen the power of the government working with the NGO's, and look forward to collaborating globally to conquer cancer," said Dr. Mohar of Mexico's National Cancer Institute.
The six call to action steps issued by the three U.S. organizations include:
1.. making vaccines that prevent cancer causing infections more widely available to low-income nations, including specifically combating cervical cancer through Global Alliance for Vaccines and Immunizations (GAVI) efforts to make the HPV vaccine accessible and affordable;
2.. committing to a comprehensive tobacco control approach in the U.S., which includes taking measures proven effective in reducing smoking rates and having Congress grant the Food and Drug Administration (FDA) authority to regulate tobacco;
3.. ratifying immediately the Framework Convention on Tobacco Control (FCTC), the first ever global public health treaty that sets forth comprehensive measures to reduce health and economic impacts of tobacco;
4.. supporting efforts of non-governmental organizations to build advocacy and resources, empower survivors and reduce suffering in low- to middle-income countries by working with governments, medical professionals and the corporate sector to enable individuals to adopt healthier behaviors;
5.. promoting culturally sensitive risk reduction and education campaigns by leveraging our own successful U.S. efforts to help build capacity of nongovernmental organizations in other countries; and
6.. investing in cancer research and expanding access to prevention and early detection measures in the U.S., with a specific focus on increasing federal funding of medical research.The news conference also featured the domestic launch of a new documentary film series focused on the global cancer problem titled "Cancer Is." The documentary is narrated by former U.S. President George H. W. Bush, and was produced by France's Cemil Alyanak, a renowned expert on global health communications.